THE LAB · RESEARCH IN PROGRESS

We test our own ideas in public. Failures included.

This is our research notebook: the questions each system is trying to answer, the data it records, what broke, and what we changed. It is the same evidence standard our books use. Most of what we test does not work, and we show that too.

  • Research, not a service. Nothing here is a signal, a track record or advice.
  • Delayed. Results are published after the week closes, never live.
  • Only broker data counts. Paper and shadow results are not used as evidence.

Updated with data to Fri 20 Nov 2026

01 · THE SYSTEMS

What each system is asking

New tests start with no results. Their rules are written down and frozen before they run, and only real demo trades will count. Results appear here once there are enough trades to say anything.

MT5 BROKER DATA · EVIDENCE

Currency strength tracker

Which currencies are strongest and weakest, and does that persist?

Records 16 currencies every 15 minutes, with the market context alongside (yields, gold, oil, volatility).

Since 3 May 2026 · 19,000+ snapshots

MT5 BROKER DATA · EVIDENCE

Structure Lab

Do common market-structure ideas hold up on real broker prices?

Logs structure events on 16 markets from M5 to monthly charts. It records and measures; it places no orders.

Since 25 Jun 2026 · 41,000+ observations

AI-BUILT · TRADING SWITCHED OFF

ATLAS

Can a system built entirely by AI, with no human judgement in its decisions, find an edge?

So far, no. Every model it has tried has been retired (see below). It now runs for data and logging only, and each new idea must pass a test written down before the numbers are run.

Trading off since 17 Oct 2026

MT5 BROKER DATA

Market recorder

What did the week actually do, on the prices a trader really sees?

Weekly open, high, low and close for the 28 major pairs, gold, silver, US indices and crypto. It feeds our free weekly market review.

Weekly since Oct 2026

DEMO ACCOUNT · EXPERIMENT

RuleGate

Does a strict, rules-only EA hold up once it trades a real broker feed?

Rules only, 1% risk per trade, on a demo account. Every closed trade is shown below, losses included.

Demo since 19 Oct 2026 · 61 trades so far

DEMO ACCOUNT · NEW

RuleGate V1 comparison

Did our October changes to RuleGate make it better, or just different?

The 13 October version runs alongside the current one, on the same markets with the same settings, so the two can be compared trade for trade.

Running since 26 Oct 2026 · no results published yet

DEMO ACCOUNT · PUBLIC RECORD

FX engine

Can an engine built on currency strength make money on a real broker feed, after costs?

Trades the major currency pairs on a demo account. Every closed trade is shown below, wins and losses, and every rule change is posted when it goes live.

Public record since 9 Nov 2026 · 216 trades so far

DEMO ACCOUNT · PUBLIC RECORD

Gold engine

Can a rules-based gold engine hold up on a real broker feed?

Trades gold on a demo account, under the same publishing rules: every trade, every rule change.

Public record since 9 Nov 2026 · 17 trades so far

DEMO ACCOUNT · NEW

OTE Lab

Does our structure-led way of drawing OTE zones do better than the usual swing-to-swing Fibonacci?

Both versions read zones on the same 46 markets and the same live feed, from M15 to weekly charts. Same entry, stop and targets for both; only the zone differs.

Started 1 Nov 2026 · no results yet

DEMO ACCOUNT · NEW

VWAP Lab

Do the common VWAP setups hold up once costs are counted?

Four setups side by side: fading the outer band, buying the trend pullback, the VWAP reclaim, and OTE zones that line up with an anchored VWAP.

Started 1 Nov 2026 · no results yet

DEMO ACCOUNT · NEW

Profile Lab

Do volume and time-at-price levels work better than random levels nearby?

Twelve setups built on our Volume Atlas and Price Dwell levels, each run against control levels placed at random, so luck can be told apart from the levels.

Started 1 Nov 2026 · no results yet

02 · SCAR TISSUE

What broke, and what we changed

Most trading brands only show the wins. This is the log of what didn't work.

WhenSystemWhat failedWhat we changed
5 Oct 2026Paper and shadow logsResults varied widely with the broker environment, so they were not reliable enough to learn from.Dropped as evidence. Only records from real broker prices now count, here and in our books.
7 Oct 2026RuleGateResults in R were not being measured correctly.R is now the net result divided by the amount risked at entry, on every trade.
17 Oct 2026ATLASIts trend-pullback and range-fade models lost money over 47 trades.Both retired, and trading switched off.
18 Oct 2026Currency strength trackerDuplicate recorders were writing two or three identical rows at a time.Reduced to one recorder; duplicates are removed before any analysis.
20 Oct 2026ATLASDaily momentum failed its pre-registered test on three markets it had never seen (−0.27R on the held-out data).Retired, with no re-cut of the test to make it pass.
Oct 2026Market feed (energy)Our feed's oil and gas quotes did not match exchange settlements, because of contract rolls and stale quotes.Published energy figures now come from exchange settlements confirmed by two sources.
25 Oct 2026RuleGate statisticsTen minutes of readings from a different account made the drawdown show as 99.9%.Those readings are now filtered out. The real figure at the time was 5.5%.
26 and 29 Oct 2026RuleGateThe three-trades-a-day cap let a fourth trade through twice. It was checked once per scan, and two signals arrived in the same scan.Fix scheduled: the cap will be checked before every trade. Both extra trades are counted in the results below.
31 Oct 2026Indicator levels (Volume Atlas, Price Dwell)A pre-registered test asked whether gold holds more often at the levels than at nearby control prices. Volume Atlas: +2.1 points, not significant. Price Dwell: +3.4 points, but it failed on the held-out data.Neither passed. Our product pages describe what the levels show and make no claim that price reacts at them.

03 · RULEGATE · DEMO ACCOUNT

Every closed trade, a week behind

Demo account, 1% risk per trade, tracking since 19 Oct. Results in R: one R is the amount risked on that trade. A break-even is a trade whose stop was moved to the entry price after it reached +1R. No broker or account details.

Closed trades61
Wins · break-even · losses11 · 20 · 30
Total−2.18R
Account change+0.05%
Worst drawdown9.0%

Cumulative result, trade by trade · dots: green = target hit, grey = break-even, red = stopped out

0R−2.18R

61 trades is far too few to judge anything. Several were on the same market on the same day, so the sample is even smaller than it looks. We will keep publishing every week, whatever the result.

Newest first. Scroll the table to see all 61 trades.

#Closed (UTC)MarketSideResultExit
61Fri 20 NovAUD/JPYShort+1.97RTake profit
60Fri 20 NovEUR/AUDLong−0.97RStop loss
59Fri 20 NovBTC/USDShort−1.03RStop loss
58Thu 19 NovXAU/USDShort−0.96RStop loss
57Wed 18 NovGER40Short−1.02RStop loss
56Wed 18 NovXAU/USDShort−1.02RStop loss
55Wed 18 NovUS500Short−0.01RBreak-even (stop at entry)
54Wed 18 NovGBP/AUDLong+0.50RStop loss
53Wed 18 NovXAU/USDShort−1.04RStop loss
52Tue 17 NovGBP/NZDLong+0.08RBreak-even (stop at entry)
51Tue 17 NovGBP/AUDLong+1.43RStop loss
50Tue 17 NovXAU/USDShort−1.03RStop loss
49Fri 13 NovXAU/USDShort+0.50RStop loss
48Fri 13 NovXAU/USDShort−1.01RStop loss
47Fri 13 NovEUR/USDShort+0.06RBreak-even (stop at entry)
46Fri 13 NovXAU/USDShort−1.08RStop loss
45Wed 11 NovGER40Long+2.00RTake profit
44Wed 11 NovNVIDIAShort−1.00RStop loss
43Wed 11 NovGER40Long−1.00RStop loss
42Tue 10 NovUS100Short+2.00RTake profit
41Tue 10 NovNVIDIAShort+1.99RTake profit
40Tue 10 NovEUR/AUDLong−0.72RStop loss
39Mon 9 NovAppleLong0.00RBreak-even (stop at entry)
38Mon 9 NovAmazonLong−0.98RStop loss
37Fri 6 NovBTC/USDShort−0.02RBreak-even (stop at entry)
36Fri 6 NovUS500Short0.00RBreak-even (stop at entry)
35Fri 6 NovEUR/AUDLong+1.97RTake profit
34Thu 5 NovUS100Short+2.00RTake profit
33Thu 5 NovGBP/JPYLong−0.79RStop loss
32Thu 5 NovGER40Long−0.01RBreak-even (stop at entry)
31Wed 4 NovCHF/JPYLong+2.00RTake profit
30Wed 4 NovAUD/JPYShort+0.08RBreak-even (stop at entry)
29Wed 4 NovUSD/CHFShort+0.10RBreak-even (stop at entry)
28Tue 3 NovCHF/JPYLong−0.03RBreak-even (stop at entry)
27Tue 3 NovUS500Short0.00RBreak-even (stop at entry)
26Tue 3 NovUS100Short−0.01RBreak-even (stop at entry)
25Mon 2 NovTeslaLong−1.00RStop loss
24Mon 2 NovGBP/AUDLong+0.08RBreak-even (stop at entry)
23Mon 2 NovXAU/USDShort−1.00RStop loss
22Mon 2 NovXAU/USDShort−1.02RStop loss
21Fri 30 OctUS30Long+2.00RTake profit
20Fri 30 OctGBP/NZDLong−1.01RStop loss
19Fri 30 OctGBP/JPYLong+0.03RBreak-even (stop at entry)
18Thu 29 OctUS100Short−0.01RBreak-even (stop at entry)
17Thu 29 OctXAU/USDShort0.00RBreak-even (stop at entry)
16Thu 29 OctGER40Long+0.01RBreak-even (stop at entry)
15Thu 29 OctGER40Long+2.02RTake profit
14Wed 28 OctUS30Long+2.02RTake profit
13Wed 28 OctGBP/CADShort−1.13RStop loss
12Wed 28 OctNVIDIAShort−1.01RStop loss
11Wed 28 OctGBP/NZDLong+2.00RTake profit
10Tue 27 OctUS100Short−1.02RStop loss
9Tue 27 OctXAU/USDShort−0.01RBreak-even (stop at entry)
8Mon 26 OctNVIDIAShort−0.99RStop loss
7Mon 26 OctUS500Short−0.99RStop loss
6Mon 26 OctUS500Short−0.01RBreak-even (stop at entry)
5Mon 26 OctUS100Short−1.00RStop loss
4Fri 23 OctXAU/USDShort−0.02RBreak-even (stop at entry)
3Fri 23 OctUS100Short−1.04RStop loss
2Thu 22 OctAUD/JPYShort−1.00RStop loss
1Thu 22 OctUS30Long−1.03RStop loss

04 · FX AND GOLD ENGINES · DEMO ACCOUNTS

Our own engines, every trade, from 9 Nov

Two of our trading engines on demo accounts: one trades the major currency pairs using currency strength, the other trades gold. From the week of 9 Nov we publish every closed trade, wins and losses, and post every rule change when it happens. Results in R (the amount risked on that trade) and in pounds, as reported by the broker, including costs. No broker or account details.

FX engine

Closed trades216
Wins · losses129 · 87
Total−6.42R
Net result−£2,739.79
Deepest dip18.74R

Cumulative result since 9 Nov, trade by trade · dots: green = win, red = loss

0R−6.42R

The record counts every trade opened from 9 Nov, when the current rules went live, wins and losses.

This week’s 115 closed trades, newest first.

#Closed (UTC)MarketSideResultP&LExit
216Fri 20 NovNZD/CADBuy−1.00R−£73.31Stop
215Fri 20 NovNZD/CHFBuy−1.00R−£511.16Stop
214Fri 20 NovAUD/CHFSell+1.47R+£166.88Target
213Fri 20 NovNZD/USDBuy−1.00R−£69.86Stop
212Fri 20 NovCAD/JPYSell+0.27R+£18.51Stop
211Fri 20 NovEUR/JPYSell+0.23R+£19.23Stop
210Fri 20 NovCAD/CHFBuy−1.00R−£521.82Stop
209Fri 20 NovNZD/JPYSell−0.06R−£4.33Stop
208Fri 20 NovGBP/CHFSell+0.17R+£25.43Engine exit
207Fri 20 NovEUR/CHFSell+0.21R+£24.53Engine exit
206Fri 20 NovGBP/CHFBuy−1.00R−£145.68Stop
205Fri 20 NovAUD/USDBuy−0.98R−£67.93Stop
204Fri 20 NovCAD/JPYSell+0.58R+£40.32Engine exit
203Fri 20 NovUSD/JPYSell+0.32R+£21.60Stop
202Fri 20 NovAUD/CADBuy−1.00R−£70.08Stop
201Fri 20 NovEUR/CHFBuy−1.00R−£113.25Stop
200Fri 20 NovEUR/USDBuy−1.00R−£75.93Stop
199Fri 20 NovAUD/JPYSell+0.29R+£19.18Stop
198Fri 20 NovEUR/JPYSell+0.22R+£19.17Stop
197Fri 20 NovNZD/JPYSell−0.92R−£61.32Engine exit
196Fri 20 NovEUR/JPYSell+0.22R+£19.19Stop
195Fri 20 NovGBP/CADBuy−0.14R−£11.72Engine exit
194Fri 20 NovEUR/GBPBuy−0.04R−£4.00Engine exit
193Fri 20 NovCAD/JPYSell+0.25R+£17.27Stop
192Fri 20 NovUSD/JPYSell−0.05R−£3.36Engine exit
191Fri 20 NovAUD/CHFSell+1.09R+£118.62Stop
190Fri 20 NovEUR/AUDBuy+0.23R+£16.77Engine exit
189Fri 20 NovAUD/NZDSell+1.15R+£56.76Stop
188Fri 20 NovGBP/NZDSell−0.27R−£23.68Engine exit
187Fri 20 NovNZD/USDSell−0.03R−£2.29Engine exit
186Fri 20 NovAUD/JPYSell+0.29R+£19.19Stop
185Fri 20 NovAUD/JPYSell+0.21R+£14.64Engine exit
184Fri 20 NovGBP/AUDBuy−0.77R−£68.40Engine exit
183Fri 20 NovEUR/AUDBuy+0.28R+£18.81Engine exit
182Thu 19 NovNZD/CADBuy−1.02R−£74.24Stop
181Thu 19 NovEUR/GBPBuy+0.38R+£41.00Engine exit
180Thu 19 NovGBP/CHFBuy−1.01R−£556.76Stop
179Thu 19 NovCAD/JPYBuy−1.01R−£68.75Stop
178Thu 19 NovEUR/JPYBuy−1.01R−£85.43Stop
177Thu 19 NovEUR/CHFBuy+0.93R+£434.43Engine exit
176Thu 19 NovNZD/USDBuy+0.77R+£53.60Engine exit
175Thu 19 NovEUR/GBPBuy+0.71R+£268.76Engine exit
174Thu 19 NovCHF/JPYBuy+0.31R+£20.93Stop
173Thu 19 NovGBP/CADBuy−1.00R−£85.83Stop
172Thu 19 NovEUR/USDBuy+0.70R+£49.43Engine exit
171Thu 19 NovCAD/JPYBuy+0.28R+£19.03Stop
170Thu 19 NovGBP/NZDSell+1.70R+£147.97Target
169Thu 19 NovNZD/JPYBuy+1.39R+£95.87Target
168Thu 19 NovEUR/CADBuy−0.05R−£3.98Engine exit
167Thu 19 NovCAD/JPYBuy+0.28R+£19.03Stop
166Thu 19 NovAUD/USDSell−1.01R−£70.39Stop
165Thu 19 NovUSD/CADBuy−1.01R−£48.32Stop
164Thu 19 NovNZD/JPYBuy+0.28R+£18.62Stop
163Thu 19 NovGBP/CADBuy+0.05R+£3.98Engine exit
162Thu 19 NovAUD/CADSell+0.17R+£11.68Engine exit
161Thu 19 NovAUD/JPYSell+0.28R+£18.86Stop
160Thu 19 NovGBP/NZDBuy+0.12R+£10.03Engine exit
159Thu 19 NovAUD/CADSell+1.82R+£437.44Target
158Thu 19 NovAUD/CHFBuy−1.01R−£449.84Stop
157Wed 18 NovNZD/CADBuy−0.07R−£22.56Engine exit
156Wed 18 NovAUD/NZDSell+0.26R+£60.15Engine exit
155Wed 18 NovGBP/NZDSell+0.15R+£51.79Engine exit
154Wed 18 NovCAD/JPYSell+0.28R+£74.44Stop
153Wed 18 NovNZD/JPYBuy−1.00R−£267.19Stop
152Wed 18 NovAUD/JPYSell−0.03R−£6.68Engine exit
151Wed 18 NovEUR/JPYSell−0.02R−£7.63Stop
150Wed 18 NovEUR/NZDSell+0.21R+£52.60Engine exit
149Wed 18 NovCHF/JPYSell+0.39R+£104.91Stop
148Wed 18 NovEUR/CADSell+0.24R+£71.19Engine exit
147Wed 18 NovCHF/JPYSell+0.08R+£22.88Engine exit
146Wed 18 NovGBP/AUDBuy−1.01R−£394.41Stop
145Wed 18 NovAUD/CHFSell−1.00R−£441.78Stop
144Wed 18 NovNZD/CADBuy+0.26R+£77.47Engine exit
143Wed 18 NovEUR/NZDSell+0.14R+£33.35Engine exit
142Wed 18 NovNZD/CADBuy−0.18R−£54.06Engine exit
141Wed 18 NovAUD/JPYSell+0.20R+£53.40Engine exit
140Wed 18 NovEUR/JPYSell+0.23R+£77.24Stop
139Wed 18 NovCAD/JPYSell+0.36R+£91.55Stop
138Wed 18 NovEUR/JPYBuy−1.00R−£321.94Stop
137Wed 18 NovEUR/NZDSell−1.00R−£268.70Stop
136Wed 18 NovAUD/JPYBuy−1.00R−£263.15Stop
135Wed 18 NovNZD/CADSell−0.89R−£258.37Stop
134Tue 17 NovNZD/JPYSell−1.00R−£281.56Stop
133Tue 17 NovEUR/USDBuy+0.40R+£122.49Engine exit
132Tue 17 NovGBP/CADBuy−0.41R−£137.86Engine exit
131Tue 17 NovEUR/AUDBuy−1.02R−£291.04Stop
130Tue 17 NovGBP/USDBuy+0.23R+£75.73Engine exit
129Tue 17 NovCHF/JPYSell−1.00R−£257.81Stop
128Tue 17 NovEUR/CADSell−0.91R−£306.27Engine exit
127Tue 17 NovNZD/JPYSell+0.28R+£75.18Stop
126Tue 17 NovNZD/CADSell+0.24R+£72.14Engine exit
125Tue 17 NovGBP/NZDBuy−0.01R−£4.17Engine exit
124Tue 17 NovAUD/JPYSell+0.28R+£75.20Stop
123Tue 17 NovEUR/AUDBuy−1.00R−£279.85Stop
122Tue 17 NovEUR/CADBuy−1.00R−£295.97Stop
121Tue 17 NovEUR/CHFBuy−1.00R−£450.42Stop
120Tue 17 NovGBP/CADBuy−0.28R−£95.43Engine exit
119Tue 17 NovAUD/CHFBuy−1.00R−£450.54Stop
118Tue 17 NovNZD/JPYSell+0.53R+£138.30Stop
117Tue 17 NovEUR/JPYSell+0.06R+£17.16Engine exit
116Tue 17 NovCAD/JPYSell+0.39R+£103.92Stop
115Tue 17 NovEUR/JPYSell+0.23R+£75.31Stop
114Tue 17 NovAUD/JPYBuy−1.00R−£266.99Stop
113Tue 17 NovEUR/JPYBuy−1.00R−£330.63Stop
112Tue 17 NovGBP/NZDBuy−0.73R−£233.50Engine exit
111Tue 17 NovGBP/AUDBuy+0.15R+£55.12Engine exit
110Tue 17 NovEUR/AUDBuy+0.17R+£46.95Engine exit
109Tue 17 NovEUR/CADBuy+0.24R+£71.01Engine exit
108Tue 17 NovGBP/AUDBuy+0.16R+£56.16Engine exit
107Tue 17 NovAUD/CADBuy+0.06R+£15.90Engine exit
106Tue 17 NovAUD/CHFBuy−0.12R−£52.36Engine exit
105Tue 17 NovEUR/JPYBuy+0.24R+£75.17Stop
104Mon 16 NovAUD/CHFSell+1.08R+£445.82Target
103Mon 16 NovCAD/JPYBuy−1.03R−£285.76Stop
102Mon 16 NovEUR/AUDBuy+1.78R+£491.55Target

Gold engine

Closed trades17
Wins · losses8 · 9
Total+5.53R
Net result+£2,810.97
Deepest dip4.56R

Cumulative result since 9 Nov, trade by trade · dots: green = win, red = loss

0R+5.53R

The record counts every trade opened from 9 Nov, when the current rules went live, wins and losses.

This week’s 12 closed trades, newest first.

#Closed (UTC)MarketSideResultP&LExit
17Fri 20 NovGoldBuy+0.50R+£299.99Stop
16Fri 20 NovGoldSell+1.86R+£850.60Target
15Fri 20 NovGoldBuy−1.00R−£428.18Stop
14Thu 19 NovGoldBuy−1.02R−£582.64Stop
13Thu 19 NovGoldSell+2.89R+£965.91Target
12Thu 19 NovGoldBuy−1.02R−£268.59Stop
11Thu 19 NovGoldBuy+0.50R+£161.31Stop
10Thu 19 NovGoldBuy−1.01R−£417.92Stop
9Wed 18 NovGoldBuy−1.00R−£206.05Stop
8Wed 18 NovGoldBuy−1.05R−£564.48Stop
7Wed 18 NovGoldBuy−0.98R−£218.43Stop
6Wed 18 NovGoldSell+2.06R+£2,100.82Target

One week is far too little to judge anything. We will keep publishing every week, whatever the result.

Rule changes

We describe what changed in general terms; the exact rules stay ours. Every change is listed here with the date it went live.

Live fromEngineChangeWhat it means
29 Oct 2026FX engineCurrency strength reading refinedWe changed how the engine measures currency strength.
29 Oct 2026FX engineTrade selection learns from our own resultsThe engine now ranks trade ideas using what its own demo results have shown so far.
29 Oct 2026Gold engineGold trade selection and targets updatedThe gold engine now ranks trade ideas using its own demo results, and its profit targets were revised.
8 Nov 2026FX engineNew entry filters and trade managementWe added filters on when the engine may enter and changed how open trades are managed.

05 · WHY WE DO THIS

The same rule as our books

A claim needs its source, its sample and its period. When the evidence is not there, we say so rather than filling the gap. The Lab holds us to that standard on our own ideas first.

Research only. Not a forecast, a signal or financial advice. These are results from our own research systems and a demo account. They are not a track record, and nothing here recommends buying or selling any instrument or using any system. Past results do not predict future results. Trading leveraged products carries a high risk of losing money.